This story was updated at 9 a.m. on Nov. 4 to reflect the most current vote counts.

Republicans were on track to win all three races for seats on the Montana Public Service Commission as final votes were counted the morning after election day, according to election results compiled by the Associated Press.

Incumbent Commissioner Tony O’Donnell, a Republican who represents Billings and Southeast Montana, was ahead by a 64-36 point margin, with 87% of the district’s precincts reporting results as of Wednesday morning. The Associated Press has called that race for O’Donnell.

Lawyer James Brown of Dillon, a Republican, appeared on track to defeat Democratic State Rep. Tom Woods of Bozeman for the seat representing Bozeman and southwest Montana on the commission. Brown was leading the race by a 54-46 point margin as of Wednesday with about 95% of precincts reported.

In the district representing Missoula and northwest Montana, state. Sen. Jennifer Fielder of Thompson Falls, a Republican, led longtime utility attorney Monica Tranel, a Missoula Democrat, by a 52-48 point margin. Tranel had previously appeared to be leading the race late Tuesday night, before results were reported from some rural counties.

The five-member Montana Public Service Commission, which has been controlled entirely by Republicans, has been beset in recent years by interpersonal conflict and scandals. That strife comes amid a wave of coal power plant closures that have utility companies, regulators and renewable energy advocates debating the future of the regional power grid.

In this year’s election, Democratic candidates argued the body could be more proactive about pushing NorthWestern to adopt renewable energy sources as a way of addressing concerns about climate change. Republican candidates, some of whom expressed skepticism about mainstream climate science, generally said they believe the regulatory body should be cautious about taking an advocacy role around renewable energy.

The PSC’s other two commissioners, Randy Pinocci of north-central Montana and Brad Johnson of Helena were out-of-cycle in 2020 and are next up for election in 2022.

related stories

grizzly bear montana

Montana petitions U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to delist NCDE grizzlies

Gov. Greg Gianforte’s office announced today that the state is petitioning the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to remove Endangered Species Act protections for grizzly bears in the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem, citing robust population counts and touting the state’s ability to independently manage Montana’s grizzly bears, which have been federally protected since 1975.

Brad Tschida

Election critics press their case for special legislative committee

Speaking to Montana’s legislative leadership Monday, Sen. Theresa Manzella and Rep. Brad Tschida pressed their case for a special committee to investigate the state’s 2020 election. The appeals came after the pair failed to convince Attorney General Austin Knudsen to sign a proposed lawsuit crafted by MyPillow founder Mike Lindell challenging the results of last…


Something went wrong. Please refresh the page and/or try again.

Eric Dietrich is a journalist and data designer and the founder of the Long Streets economic reporting project. His reporting focuses broadly on Montana’s governance and economic opportunity, with particular focus on the state budget and tax policy. He also contributes data reporting across the MTFP newsroom. Before joining the MTFP staff in 2019, he worked for the Great Falls Tribune, Bozeman Daily Chronicle, and Solutions Journalism Network and also earned an engineering degree from Montana State University. Contact Eric at, 406-465-3386 ext. 2, and follow him on Twitter.