
Get an insider’s look into what’s happening in and around the halls of power with expert reporting, analysis and insight from the editors and reporters of Montana Free Press. Sign up to get the free Capitolized newsletter delivered to your inbox every Thursday.
April 3, 2025
The day after state senators shot down a pair of bills that would have implemented his signature tax policy initiatives — one a hefty income tax cut and the other a property tax measure aimed at offering tax relief to frustrated homeowners — Gov. Greg Gianforte put on a brave face for reporters.
“I fundamentally believe Montanans sent policymakers to Helena to address the challenges that Montanans face,” the Republican governor said at a Thursday press conference. “Our focus remains on delivering meaningful solutions for those challenges, cutting property taxes without further burdening income tax payers, cutting the income tax rate most Montanans pay, and creating a high-quality education system and standing up for the most fundamental responsibilities of government: to keep our people safe.”
With Gianforte’s bills just two among many tax measures introduced at this year’s Legislature, their demise is by no means the end of the story as he and various legislative factions negotiate over property and income tax policy. It’s also possible, perhaps even likely, that one or both of his proposals rise again in some form before the session wraps up in the coming weeks.
This week’s votes do, however, signal that Gianforte’s ideas are facing significant bipartisan opposition.
On the income tax side, critics have expressed concern that the governor’s proposed cut, which would reduce the state’s primary income tax rate from 5.9% to 4.9%, would eventually cause a budget crunch by reducing revenues by roughly $300 million a year. Republicans and Democrats in the Legislature are advancing alternative proposals that come with smaller price tags, in some cases focusing tax relief only on lower- and middle-income taxpayers.
Gianforte, though, insisted Thursday that he wants an income tax cut that reduces taxes for Montanans at all points on the income spectrum — high-income taxpayers included. Eventually, he said, he wants Montana to have a “flat” tax system with a single income tax rate — as opposed to a comparatively progressive multi-tier system that taxes higher incomes at higher marginal rates.
Asked by Capitolized why he thinks a progressive rate structure is bad policy for Montana, Gianforte said a flat tax system with provisions to help low-income working taxpayers would more fairly fund state operations.
“When you get to a flat tax, as many other states have done, or eliminate income tax entirely, you have a fairer system because everyone shares the burden based on their income level,” Gianforte said, noting he does support an expanded earned income tax credit, which would reduce taxes for lower-income workers and families.
“That’s what we’re advocating for,” he said.
Gianforte also said he’s confident that economic growth will help offset the expense of his proposed income tax cut.
“We reduced income tax rates in 2021 and the economy boomed. We lowered income tax rates in 2023 and the economy boomed,” he said. “The strategy that we’ve laid out and implemented is working. It’s time to do the next step.”
Gianforte did, however, acknowledge that he thinks there’s room for “honest debate” with lawmakers over how much to lower the state’s main tax rate.
The governor’s desire to reduce state government’s reliance on income taxes imposes a tough constraint on the debate over property tax relief.
In contrast to state income taxes, which support services like health programs and prisons, most Montana property taxes fund local services such as schools and law enforcement — places where most lawmakers haven’t wanted to force immediate service cuts. As a result, the sticking point for the property tax discussion this year has been figuring out where the money necessary to pay for homeowner property tax relief will come from.
Lawmakers have proposed several property tax relief bills that would directly or indirectly tap the state’s income-tax-fueled General Fund. That fund is currently running a healthy surplus — the same surplus that gives Gianforte space to push for lower income taxes while proposing extra spending on K-12 teacher pay and public safety initiatives.
Another approach favored by some lawmakers is shifting taxes between different types of property, perhaps by increasing taxes on farms or industrial properties in order to lower taxes on homes. Supporters argue that would offset the higher taxes pulled onto residential properties by surging home prices in recent years, but business groups have resisted proposals that would boost their taxes.
The Gianforte-backed tax plan, drafted by Rep. Llew Jones, R-Conrad, takes a tax-shift approach to bump down taxes for homeowners and landlords, but boosts taxes on second homes and Airbnb-style short-term rentals in an effort to minimize its tax shift onto business properties. It also includes a provision aimed at reducing taxes on lower-value businesses.
Gianforte, who has called that bill a “homestead” approach, maintained Thursday that he believes it’s the best property tax solution on the table.
“It would lower taxes for homeowners by about 15%, it would lower taxes for small businesses by about 18%, it would benefit renters — it’s the fairest approach that will offer permanent tax relief,” he said.
He also reiterated Thursday that he sees property tax reduction as a must-pass priority before the Legislature wraps up this year.
“We can’t leave here without implementing permanent property tax relief for the people of Montana. And we can’t do it, we won’t do it, by further burdening income tax payers by taking money out of the General Fund.”
—Eric Dietrich
Taking Rules to rule the roost
Minutes after the Senate on Tuesday imposed a lifetime floor ban and two-year committee ban on former chamber leader Jason Ellsworth, R-Hamilton, moves were underway to fill one of those vacant committee seats.
Sen. Josh Kassmier, R-Fort Benton, rose after the 44-6 vote to censure Ellsworth and proposed filling Ellsworth’s vacated seat on the Senate Rules Committee with Sen. Gregg Hunter, R-Glasgow.

In addition to the ban from the floor and removal from committees, Ellsworth was also prohibited from initiating communications with legislative staff or government department heads, and banned from legislative branch offices. The censure stems from an ethics investigation into a government contract Ellsworth awarded to a friend without disclosing the relationship.
Kassmier’s move to put Hunter on the Rules Committee drew the ire of conservatives Wednesday.
“The sponsor of the motion has been stacking the Rules Committee with people. For what purpose, I’m not sure. But I mean, we’ve already had one motion to put two people on there. … So, to what end?” said Sen. Daniel Emrich, R-Great Falls.
The motion to put Hunter on the committee passed 28-22.

To rule Rules is to rule the roost. There are nine Republicans who on Day 1 of the session coalesced with minority-party Democrats to form a formidable voting bloc on key issues. This group has a voting edge on the Rules Committee. Earlier in the session, the coalition appointed members of their group to several Senate committees, including Rules, which is what Emrich referenced.
And the Rules Committee has incoming business, that being a request from Sen. Shelley Vance, R-Belgrade, to refer a contracting matter concerning Senate President Matt Regier, R-Kalispell, to the Senate Ethics Committee. Vance requested on March 27 that the Rules Committee consider Regier’s hiring of outside legal counsel. It takes only one senator to request the committee take a look because those are the rules as they were published in 2023. Due to lack of agreement, the Senate hasn’t been able to adopt permanent rules for the 2025 session.
“I don’t think I’m stacking,” Kassmier said Wednesday. “I’m just appointing another member after we removed a member, and Sen. Hunter as a freshman has shown great effort. He knows the process well, and I don’t know why we would object to putting a Republican on the Rules.”
But to Emrich it was curious that no Senate Democrats objected.
“I’m really curious as to why the caucus on the other side doesn’t have a problem with that,” he said.
—Tom Lutey
Watching flowers on the wall
Republican Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen, just days removed from a state Supreme Court hearing on his possible punishment for judicial conduct violations, told Missoula radio listeners that findings against him were the product of a “kangaroo court.”
Justices on the panel reviewing Knudsen’s case March 28 raised concerns about proceedings against the attorney general last October, including that it occurred weeks before a general election. Knudsen easily won a second term.
Supreme Court Chief Justice Cory Swanson questioned why, despite alleging 41 conduct charges against Knudsen, the Office of Disciplinary Counsel detailed only six of the charges in filings ahead of the March 28 review.
“It was kind of a kangaroo court. I’ll just say it out loud,” Knudsen told listeners of KGVO radio. “They didn’t let me present evidence. They didn’t let me refute several of their witnesses. They ruled on motions without giving me time to respond in writing, which happens in every court case. You get to respond in writing.”
The attorney general characterized his behavior that resulted in proceedings as “saying critical things about the court” while representing the 2021 Legislature in a battle over subpoena power with the state Supreme Court.
The attorney general did note that judges reviewing the case March 28 did have some critical questions for Knudsen too. The attorney general had refused to comply with a court order in 2021.
Knudsen said that he didn’t expect to hear back from the justices for at least a month on what, if any, punishment he might serve. The Commission on Practice had recommended Knudsen be punished for conduct violations, which aren’t criminal. The maximum penalty would be a 90-day suspension of the attorney general’s law license. Knudsen has argued that the case against him be thrown out, or that the punishment be lenient.
—Tom Lutey
On Background
- Senate committee votes down Gianforte’s income tax cut, property tax relief bills.
- A coalition of nine Republicans and the 18-member Democratic minority coalesced on the first day of the 2025 Legislature to form a powerful voting bloc.
- What’s behind the conduct complaint against Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen.
- New state Supreme Court Chief Justice Cory Swanson, endorsed for office by the Republican leadership in 2024, warned legislators against making judicial elections partisan.


