District Court Judge Jeffrey Dahood discusses the charges with County Attorney Morgan Smith and Michael Paul Brown’s attorneys, Christopher White and Walter Hennessey, from the Office of the State Public Defender, during the arraignment hearing on Wednesday, Sept. 3, 2025, in Anaconda. Brown is charged with four counts of deliberate homicide, as well as arson, theft and evading law enforcement in connection with the deadly Aug. 1 shooting at the Owl Bar. Credit: Lauren Miller/MTFP/CatchLight/Report for America

The man facing homicide charges for the fatal shootings of four people at an Anaconda bar in 2025 is still undergoing treatment at the Montana State Hospital in Warm Springs in an effort to declare him fit to stand trial.

Michael Paul Brown, the Anaconda resident accused of shooting and killing other residents of the southwest Montana town at the Owl Bar last August, appeared virtually for a status hearing before state District Court Judge Jeffrey Dahood Monday. 

Brown had pleaded not guilty in September to separate counts of arson, homicide, theft and evading law enforcement. 

In her remarks to the court, Anaconda-Deer Lodge County Attorney Morgan Smith said that she and Brown’s attorney had jointly filed a motion in mid-December to have the defendant undergo a mental health evaluation to determine his competency to move forward with a trial. But Smith said that Brown had not actually been admitted to the forensic unit at Warm Springs until roughly a month later, on Jan. 12. 

“The defendant has been evaluated, and the state hospital has developed an individualized treatment plan, as is required by statute, to assist in regaining fitness,” Smith said. “Where we sit today, your honor, is that the treatment plan remains ongoing.”

Zoom screenshot
Michael Paul Brown, left, sits next to his attorney, Walter M. Hennessey, during a virtual appearance for a status hearing in his case on Monday, Mar. 16, 2026.

Smith did not disclose or describe what kind of treatment Brown had received, or for what specific condition.

Brown, wearing a green t-shirt and with a long beard, could be seen chatting with his attorney before the morning proceedings began. After Dahood initiated the hearing, Brown sat quietly but appeared attentive.

In her brief remarks during the hearing, which lasted less than 10 minutes, Smith also noted that the state was considering an additional motion to pursue involuntary medication for Brown, but that prosecutors were not prepared to make that request to the court Monday.

“We’re not in a position to make that request today, as we’re looking to have some additional documentation with the Montana State Hospital before we have appropriate filings before the court,” Smith said. “The state’s ask at this time, your honor, is that the defendant remain at the Montana State Hospital pursuant to the court’s order.”

As outlined in state law, a judge must approve the state’s ability to involuntarily medicate someone so that they may be found fit to stand trial. That step is authorized only if a treatment review committee and a special medication review board at the Montana State Hospital determine that a set of criteria has been met. 

Those criteria include finding that the defendant in the case “suffers from a mental illness or mental disorder,” has been found to lack fitness to proceed to trial and that involuntary medication “is in the best medical interests of the defendant.” The law also requires that a defendant have the right to participate in a dedicated involuntary medication hearing and the opportunity to appeal. 

Smith said she and Brown’s defense attorney, Walter M. Hennessey, had agreed on a status hearing update in 60 days. The county attorney also noted that the prosecution would reserve the right to request an additional, independent mental health evaluation.

Hennessey did not object to anything during the brief Monday hearing, but noted that could change if the state pursued an involuntary medication proceeding, commonly referred to as a Sell hearing.

“We will address the Sell issue once they file their pleadings, and we will respond and deal with that at the appropriate time,” Hennessey said. “As for them reserving the right to an independent mental health evaluation, I don’t have any problem with that. I’m going to reserve any objections because we don’t know how this is gonna develop.”

Dahood set the next status hearing for May 13.

LATEST STORIES

Four key takeaways from the governor’s state budget proposal 

Among the most notable inclusions in Gov. Gianforte’s 2028-2029 budget proposal are a single-rate reduced income tax, infusions for state employees’ health plan and bonuses, and a $300 million transfer to a frequently debated savings account. Among the omissions are allocations recommended by a bipartisan decennial study on school funding.

Mara Silvers is the managing editor at Montana Free Press, where she has covered health policy, social services, politics and the judiciary since 2020. She was a 2023 data fellow with the USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalism, where she reported on racial disparities in Montana foster care. Mara has also helped produce and report audio projects for MTFP, including The Session and Shared State. Prior to MTFP, Mara was a radio and podcast producer for Slate, WNYC and Montana Public Radio. Her work has been featured in ProPublica, The Guardian and NPR. She lives in Helena, where she was born...