Get an insider’s look into what’s happening in and around the halls of power with expert reporting, analysis and insight from the editors and reporters of Montana Free Press. Sign up to get the free Capitolized newsletter delivered to your inbox every Thursday.
June 18, 2026
Alani Bankhead chose the location of her first big announcement as the Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate with purpose.
She made that announcement while standing within 50 yards of Main Hall at the University of Montana in Missoula, where independent candidate Seth Bodnar had spent the previous eight years as UM’s president before resigning to pursue his own U.S. Senate campaign.
“As the leader of the University of Montana, Seth settled a lawsuit with 18 female plaintiffs for sexual discrimination to the tune of $350,000,” Bankhead said Monday, delivering a blistering broadside designed to compel the attention of Democratic women, the party’s biggest voting bloc.
Bankhead encouraged Bodnar, a Rhodes Scholar and West Point graduate, to “read the room and drop out” — exactly what Bodnar supporters hoped Bankhead would do to clear the path for the better-financed and better-organized independent.
The lawsuit Bankhead referenced was originally filed in 2021 and included 18 female University of Montana employees suing the University of Montana, the Montana University System, and John Does 1-50, alleging that UM had violated the anti-discrimination policies of Title IX, a federal statute enforceable by the U.S. Department of Education. UM is required to follow Title IX as a recipient of federal funding.
The lawsuit was settled in 2024, and the settlement was sealed by the court, making it impossible for the public to see the details that brought the lawsuit to an end.
In the original complaint, the plaintiffs suggested that the university’s focus on athletics as a source of revenue and alumni outreach had “fostered a good ol’ boys club culture, favoring male athletes and employees, while excluding women from participation in activities and benefits regularly afforded to their male counterparts.”
The earliest issues raised by the plaintiffs predated Bodnar’s 2018 arrival at UM by several years. Bodnar himself is not a party to the lawsuit. The plaintiffs did, however, cite instances involving Bodnar in which they thought the university was creating obstacles to their career advancement based on assessments of their age and attractiveness. They believed they were not receiving the same opportunities for advancement as younger, more athletically built women and men.
One of the women, Catherine Cole, former vice president of enrollment management and strategic communications, alleged that her $170,000 starting salary was less than that of her male counterparts. Cole received good performance reviews, but felt Bodnar set unreasonable expectations, and according to the lawsuit informed her that she was moody and asked her to smile. Cole indicated in the lawsuit that she felt compelled to resign in 2020.
Barbara Koostra, director of UM’s Montana Museum of Arts and Culture, butted heads with the administration over the handling of its $25 million art collection. Koostra said the collection needed more care than Bodnar was allowing, but her advice wasn’t taken. She alleged in the lawsuit that she had been assigned to an office space in McGill Hall that had asbestos issues.
In 2018, less than a year after Bodnar’s arrival, Koostra was informed that her contract wouldn’t be renewed. She was half a year short of qualifying for full retirement benefits.
Other plaintiffs described similar allegations.
In response to questions raised about the lawsuit during the Senate campaign, Bodnar has said that during his tenure the university went from one female dean to seven. Seventy-eight percent of campus employee promotions during Bodnar’s tenure were for women, according to Bodnar’s campaign.
The settlement’s payment breakdown was made public in a court order approving the amounts, which totaled $350,000. Attorneys’ fees totaling $116,666.67 and litigation costs totaling $199,934.55 accounted for most of the settlement’s cost.
Payments to the plaintiffs totaled $33,398.78, or $1,855.49 each.
—Tom Lutey
Bankhead and Bodnar play chicken for Dem votes
When Alani Bankhead advised the media on June 12 that she would deliver a major campaign announcement the following Monday, a lot of Democrats assumed their party’s new U.S. Senate nominee was going to drop out.
Screenshots of Bankhead’s media advisory began popping up in mobile phone alerts. Liberal podcast culture signaled its readiness for a turncoat moment in which the Air Force veteran, who lives in Helena, ended her campaign to get out of the way of independent Seth Bodnar, who had already lined up much of what passes for institutional Democratic power behind his run.
Nope.
“If dropping out was the right move to pave the way for a better candidate, I would absolutely do it, because the stakes are so high,” Bankhead said on the oval of the University of Montana. “But Seth Bodner is absolutely the last person on the face of the earth that I would ever drop out of this race for.”
Bodnar, the best-funded candidate in the four-way race to replace incumbent Republican U.S. Sen. Steve Daines, has a lot of support from prominent Democrats. Former Democratic U.S. Sens. Max Baucus and Jon Tester are both fundraising for Bodnar, who they say has the best chance of defeating Republican Kurt Alme. The Democratic Party’s most experienced campaign staff and three of its supporting PACs have gravitated to Bodnar.
But there’s also a never-Seth faction that includes former Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer, who won election easily during a brief party revival in the early 2000s.
For now, Bodnar and Bankhead seem destined for mutual destruction, with Bodnar’s odds undermined by whatever percentage of Democrats stick with Bankhead. Bankhead, for her part, exited the primary with less than $24,000 to campaign on, an amount resembling a rounding error relative to Bodnar’s $2.1 million in contributions and Alme’s $1.2 million.
Democratic diehards haven’t matched their convictions with campaign cash. Reported contributions to the state party’s four-candidate primary field were the lowest recorded for a Democratic U.S. Senate primary in decades.
Needless to say, Republicans are tickled. On Friday, the state GOP’s most prominent political operative, Jake Eaton, shared a poll indicating that Alme is leading all comers with 45% of likely voters, while Bankhead and Bodnar split the remainder.
Kyle Austin, who won the Libertarian primary, was supported by 4% of voters polled.
—Tom Lutey
