Authorities in Cascade County have issued a warrant for Nathan Ross Harlan for allegedly forging signatures on petitions to get two independent candidates on the fall ballot.
Cascade County Attorney Josh Racki said in a press release Tuesday that investigators working on the case over several months found voters who had signatures on the petitions but said they hadn’t signed them.
The petitions relate to the campaigns of Michael Eisenhauer, the independent candidate running for U.S. House in the Eastern Congressional District, and Seth Bodnar, the independent candidate running for Montana’s open U.S. Senate seat. Authorities have said that neither campaign is accused of any wrongdoing.
“I’m grateful to Cascade County’s election officials, sheriff and county attorney for their diligence,” Montana Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen said as part of Racki’s press release Tuesday.
Around 800 signatures were called into question during the investigation, and none of them were counted toward the qualification totals for either candidate. Racki didn’t say Tuesday how many signatures were allegedly found to be fraudulent.
Eisenhauer’s and Bodnar’s campaigns hired Ballot Access Marketing, which in turn subcontracted signature gathering to Sun Belt Strategies, a firm run by Harlan, according to a court affidavit filed by the Cascade County Attorney’s Office. Harlan appeared to be based in Oxford, Mississippi, and began work in February. He purchased a voter file from the Montana Secretary of State’s Office in March, the affidavit said. That file contained the names and addresses of voters in Cascade County.
RELATED
Cascade Co. investigating independent signature gathering. House candidate Miller files lawsuit.Â
Cascade County law enforcement agencies are investigating about 800 potentially bogus signatures gathered by at least one petitioner working to qualify Michael Eisenhauer, the independent candidate running for U.S. House in the Eastern Congressional District, and Seth Bodnar, the independent candidate running for Montana’s open U.S. Senate seat. None of the signatures under investigation were counted toward either candidate’s ballot-qualification total, and Cascade County law enforcement suspects neither campaign of wrongdoing. Eastern District candidate Brian Miller has filed a lawsuit to disqualify some of the signatures.
In April, Ballot Access Marketing owner Christopher Thrasher terminated Harlan’s contract for work on Eisenhauer’s campaign after he failed to gather 9,000 signatures. Thrasher demanded the $5,000 up-front fee he paid to Harlan, court documents state.
In May, Cascade County election officials noticed issues with petition packets. They contained similar handwriting on multiple petition entries and signatures that didn’t match voter records, court documents state. One election office staffer noticed her daughter’s name on a petition line, though her daughter lives outside of Montana. Staff called some voters to ask about their signatures not matching those on file, and some of them said they hadn’t signed anything.
Elections staff noted several issues with signatures allegedly collected by “Steven Ball” and “Manuel Diaz,” both of whom may be aliases or not real people, according to the county attorney’s affidavit. Thrasher at Ballot Access Marketing told authorities that he understood those names to be people working with Harlan. Authorities aren’t sure whether Ball and Diaz worked for Harlan or were names used by Harlan, according to the affidavit.
In total, four petition “packets” became suspicious. Three of the packets included 25 pages and between 200 and 250 signatures. A fourth packet contained 95 signatures.
Throughout July and August, investigators reviewed the suspicious signature packets and tried to contact the people behind the signatures. For one packet, 51 people said they didn’t sign the petition. In others, a couple voters attested they didn’t sign a petition. In either case, the entire packets weren’t counted, because they carried the unsworn declarations of Diaz or Ball.
While the investigation was ongoing, Democratic congressional candidate Brian Miller filed a lawsuit, arguing that potentially fraudulent signatures should invalidate other petitions filed in the same batch — potentially thousands of signatures in total.
In September, Miller, an attorney, dropped his lawsuit, saying he had too much on his plate to pursue it. He is running against Eisenhauer and incumbent Republican Congressman Troy Downing.
Harlan faces four misdemeanor charges of accountability for deceptive election practices.
Harlan remains at large, and the Cascade County Sheriff’s Office has asked the public for any information about his location. Authorities found addresses associated with Harlan in nine southern states, as well as multiple phone numbers.
Racki called a press conference for 8 a.m. Wednesday to discuss details of the case.
This article was updated Oct. 27, 2026, to reflect additional information from court documents.

In-depth, independent reporting on the stories impacting your community from reporters who know your town.
LATEST STORIES
Cooke City forest project returns with smaller footprint, lingering questions
After legal threat and months of public criticism, the Forest Service has revised its proposal. But disagreements persist over how best to protect the forest and community.
Missoula County moves forward with data center regulations
Missoula County will update its data center zoning regulations after the commissioners unanimously accepted a study outlining the impacts of those developments and its recommendations.
From bus routes to ball games, diesel prices are squeezing rural Montana school budgets
Rural school districts across the state are coping with the elevated price of diesel. That means hard choices for rural schools that face long drives to students’ homes and even longer trips for major, statewide competitions.


