Montana Fish Wildlife & Parks. Credit: Eliza Wiley / MTFP

A late-October lawsuit filed by a current administrator at Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks raises questions about the tenure of the agency’s former director, Dustin Temple, who retired in 2024. The lawsuit alleges that Temple used his professional authority to sexually coerce the employee and “sabotage her career.”

Deborah O’Neill, the special projects administrator at FWP, filed the lawsuit in Lewis and Clark County District Court on Oct. 30. O’Neill seeks damages from FWP and Temple for the alleged impact on her well-being, reputation and compensation.

The lawsuit has not been previously reported. 

Garrett Turner, chief of external affairs & strategic communications at FWP, wrote Tuesday in response to questions that the agency declined to comment.

“While we don’t comment on ongoing litigation, under Director Christy Clark’s leadership, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks is committed to fostering a culture where employees feel safe, respected, and supported,” Turner wrote. 

Montana Free Press was unable to reach Dustin Temple before publication. 

The lawsuit alleges that Temple, one of O’Neill’s direct supervisors from 2021 to 2024, used his authority to coerce O’Neill into a sexual relationship and control her career. 

“[This case] is about a senior state official who used the power of his office to identify, cultivate, isolate, and exploit a subordinate employee,” O’Neill’s attorney, Adrienne Tranel, wrote in a court filing.  

O’Neill started with FWP in 2010 as a fish and wildlife plan coordinator, according to her LinkedIn profile. She took her current job as special projects administrator in 2021. 

Temple spent 20 years at FWP. From June 2023 to December 2024, he was the agency’s director. He had previously served as deputy director and chief of administration. 

O’Neill and Temple became friends in 2015 and began a sexual relationship in 2021, according to court filings. The suit alleges that Temple used his authority to stifle O’Neill’s advancement opportunities in 2023 and 2024. It also says Temple told O’Neill not to disclose their relationship to the agency’s human resources department. The lawsuit alleges that O’Neill informed FWP Human Resources Manager Jeff Kirksey of her relationship with Temple in January 2025, after Temple’s departure from the agency. 

Temple left his post as director of FWP in December 2024. A press release from the governor’s office said Temple was retiring. 

The lawsuit alleges that Gov. Greg Gianforte pressured Temple to step down from the agency. The lawsuit also posits the existence of a “state-level investigation [of Temple] regarding an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate.”

In response to questions, a spokesperson for Gianforte wrote that “while the governor’s office generally doesn’t comment on ongoing litigation, Governor Gianforte takes seriously any allegation of misconduct in his administration.”

Gianforte’s office did not address the lawsuit’s claim that the governor pressured Temple to step down or reference a state-level investigation.

LATEST STORIES

Judge blocks enforcement of sex-definition bill 

The state cannot enforce a 2025 law defining sex as binary based on a person’s reproductive system, a judge has ordered. Missoula County District Court Judge Leslie Halligan Tuesday granted the preliminary injunction in a lawsuit brought by Helena-based Upper Seven Law on behalf of a group of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans while…

Lame duck season

Wildfire, wilderness, public lands legislation awaits Congressional end-of-year scramble

No green light for proposed 24% raise for Billings superintendent, even amid leadership praise

The Board of Trustees didn’t take an up-or-down vote on the proposed 24% raise for Billings Public Schools superintendent Erwin Garcia at its meeting, but instead referred the question of whether to amend Garcia’s current contract to a committee. Garcia said he and his family would “love” to stay in Billings, calling it “an amazing…

Zeke Lloyd writes about labor, business and criminal justice for Montana Free Press. Prior to his current role, he worked as a wildfire reporting intern at MTFP in 2024 and spent a summer writing for the Colorado Springs Gazette. He is a graduate of Colorado College, where he worked at the student newspaper. He grew up in central Ohio and is now based in Helena. You can reach him at [email protected].