WEST YELLOWSTONE โ Federal employees have returned to work at public lands throughout the nation, but the cost of keeping national parks open during the record-length partial government shutdown remains unknown.
Former park employees and public-lands advocates decried the Trump administrationโs decision to keep national parks open and operating with skeleton crews. As trash piled up and natural features were destroyed in certain areas, the parks became a publicโrelations nightmare. In response, acting Secretary of the Interior David Bernhardt directed the National Park Service to tap fee reserves to support law enforcement, sanitation, safety, and emergency services.
Those reserves come from revenue generated by park entrance fees and campground fees, and are allocated to stay within the park system for visitor experience enhancement projects under the Federal Lands Recreation Enhancement Act, or FLREA. While NPS has broad discretion in how it invests FLREA funds, the funds are mostly used to benefit visitors by installing signs, restoring habitat, creating interpretive programs, and chipping away at a multi-billion dollar maintenance backlog.
Fees werenโt collected during the 35-day shutdown, but FLREA dollars were siphoned to keep the parks operating. There appears to be no plan to replenish them.
โMany people who Iโve spoken to think that probably wonโt happen. Weโll have to wait and see,โ Phil Francis, retired superintendent of the Blue Ridge Parkway and a former deputy superintendent of Great Smoky Mountains National Park, said in an interview.
Francis is also chair of the Coalition to Protect Americaโs National Parks, a group of current and former National Park Service employees and volunteers.
During the shutdown, the coalition urged the federal government to close national parks. Francis was particularly concerned about the use of FLREA funds.
โYou wouldnโt open the doors to the Smithsonian Institution and say, โCome on in. By the way, we donโt have any staff here,โโ Francis said. โIt sounds to me that weโre spending all those fee funds in order to lessen the impacts of the government shutdown for political reasons.โ
โLeaving holesโ
Reimbursing the National Park Service for its depleted FLREA money would take a congressional appropriation.
Montana Republican Sen. Steve Daines, a member of the Senate Appropriations Committee, sent a letter to the Interior Department on Jan. 5 pressuring the agency to keep the parks open and fund critical operations during the shutdown โ the same day Bernhardt told the National Park Service to start using FLREA funds. Dainesโs office claims his letter resulted in that decision.
Despite multiple inquiries, Dainesโs office would not say whether the senator will request an account of how FLREA dollars were spent or whether he will push to replenish those funds.

โSen. Daines worked to minimize the impacts of the government shutdown for all Montanans, which included his request that essential services at our National Parks remain running during the shutdown,โ his office said in an email Monday afternoon. โThe Senator will continue to work to prevent future shutdowns, and be a responsible steward of taxpayer dollars.โ
Daines did not respond to multiple interview requests.
Update: In an email statement sent to Montana Free Press on Jan. 31., Dainesโs spokeswoman, Katie Schoettler, said: โAs a Member of the U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee, the Senator will be requesting information regarding the FLREA funds, what funds had been obligated, what funds had not been obligated and overall impacts, from the Interior Department during the budget process this Congress.โ
A representative from Sen. Jon Testerโs office said itโs unclear if thereโs a plan to restore FLREA funds. He said Tester, a Democrat, does not support redirecting NPS fees to pay for operations normally funded by Congress.
โ[Sen. Tester] equates it to robbing Peter to pay Paul. Those entrance fees are marked to go to certain needs to pay for the parks,โ said Tester spokesman Dave Kuntz. โIf youโre shifting them to something else, youโre leaving other holes in the park budget.โ
Testerโs office was unable to determine how much FLREA revenue was spent during the shutdown. Tester also serves on the Senate Appropriations Committee, and Kuntz said the panel will investigate the costs of the shutdown.
Information roadblocks
While FLREA funds kept visitors flowing through national parks, the amount of public information coming from the National Park Service slowed to a dribble. Some park officials were gagged from discussing shutdown issues with the national media.
NPS Chief Spokesman Mike Litterst said FLREA funds were supporting trash removal, snow plowing, campground services, and the dissemination of safety information. NPS employees providing those services were paid during the shutdown using FLREA funds, Litterst said.
But it remains unclear how much FLREA revenue was spent during the shutdown.
โWe donโt have information we can provide on the amount or availability of funds,โ Litterest said in an email on Jan. 23.
He said on Tuesday afternoon that it would be โsome timeโ before figures become available.

The National Park Serviceโs 2018 Budget Justification estimated $285 million in recreational fee revenue for fiscal year 2018. Most of that revenue stays in the park where the fees are collected, but not all parks collect fees.
Some parks retain up to 80 percent of their FLREA funds. The remainder goes to a central NPS fund to be used for projects at other parks. Yellowstone National Park, for example, collected $15.4 million FLREA dollars in 2018 and retained $11.9 million.
Eighty-five parks, monuments, historic sites, and other NPS units used FLREA funds to remain open during the partial government shutdown. Nearly half of those sites donโt collect entrance fees, one of the biggest sources of FLREA revenue.
Yellowstone National Park was among the NPS units using FLREA reserves to keep its gates open. The park furloughed more than 200 employees during the shutdown, according to Linda Veress with the Yellowstone public affairs office. As of Tuesday, Veress said, she had not received any back pay.
About 85 โexceptedโ employees worked at Yellowstone during the shutdown, providing law enforcement, maintenance, and other basic services. โFor two weeks, some of these people were paidโ with FLREA funds, according to a โFrequently Asked Questions about Shutdownโ statement from the public affairs office.
Another 15 Yellowstone National Park employees groomed trails. They were paid through donations from concessionaires like Jerry Johnson.
Johnson owns Backcountry Adventures in West Yellowstone, a small, family-run snowmobile guide service that has been in business since the 1950s. Johnson chipped in $300 daily to help groom Yellowstoneโs trails.
โThat doesnโt seem like much, but when itโs been 15 days, it adds up,โ Johnson said. โI donโt think Iโll get any of it back.โ

It cost 13 businesses just shy of $8,000 a day to keep about 300 miles of trails and roads open to visitors and guided tours. The Yellowstone public affairs office reports that concessionaires donated $280,250 during the course of the shutdown.
โI donโt think itโs our role to support park services beyond our franchise. And yet weโre doing it anyway,โ Johnson said.
But if Yellowstone had been closed for the duration of the shutdown, โit would be bad,โ Johnson said. โFourteen people in my shop would not have jobs.โ
โPolitics out of parksโ
At least one group sees a silver lining to the National Park Serviceโs experiment of using FLREA funds during the shutdown.
โ[The shutdown] demonstrates the importance of getting politics out of our parks as much as we can,โ said Shawn Regan with the Bozeman-based Property and Environment Research Center, or PERC, a free market-focused think tank. โI think it also demonstrates the benefits to making the park system more self-sufficient and less reliant on what are really unreliable appropriations from Congress.โ
PERCโs writers have been busy making their case since shortly after the shutdown began, publishing multiple op-eds in national publications such as Outside magazine and The Hill.
โSome of the major parks can generate a lot of fee revenue from visitors,โ said Regan, a former ranger at Olympic National Park.

National parks depend on Congress for the bulk of their funding, but thatโs unsustainable, Regan argues.
In 2018, for example, NPS requested $2.6 billion in appropriations. Thatโs less than one-sixteenth of one percent of the nationโs $4.1 trillion in expenditures. Yet parks remain notoriously underfunded, currently running an $11.6 billion backlog in deferred maintenance.
While visitor fees canโt solve all of the National Park Serviceโs financial woes, Regan argues that giving park managers more control over FLREA revenue could save them from the whims of Washington, D.C.
โParks get caught in the crossfire in these political fights,โ Regan said. โParks get used as pawns.โ
When the Obama administration shuttered parks during the 2013 government shutdown, for example, some Republicans claimed it was a strategy to stir public ire and play up the pain of the closure.
This time around, some opponents of President Donald Trump claim the parks were left open to ease public pressure during the shutdown.

But park advocates argue that funding must be tied to the political process, despite its volatility.
โI appreciate PERCโs interest in finding a sustainable way to fund our parks, but the parks are funded by the federal government so all our citizens have access,โ said Francis, the retired NPS superintendent. โIf we begin to operate parks purely on a business model like we might at Disneyland, the [entrance] price would be so high it would probably exclude a lot of families from being able to attend.โ
Keeping parks open during the shutdown and tapping an unknown amount of FLREA revenue will likely have long-lasting consequences, Francis said.
If the FLREA money isnโt replenished, Francis said, then wildlife restoration projects could get slashed, campground improvement projects could be delayed, and seasonal programs could see setbacks. Above all, Francis said, he worries about the toll the shutdown could have on federal workers.
โItโs not something people get over. People remember,โ Francis said. โI hope Congress will pass legislation so this can never happen again. Weโve done this too many times to our employees and parks.โ
Editorโs note: Our original story, published Jan. 30, was updated on Jan. 31, with an additional statement from Sen. Steve Daineโs office.


