The guilty verdict in the official misconduct case against former Senate President Jason Ellsworth has been thrown out following revelations that jurors were exposed to sealed exhibits concerning communications with a potential key witness.
Lewis and Clark County District Judge Christopher Abbott said in a Wednesday court hearing that he learned Wednesday morning that jurors deliberating in the misdemeanor trial were inadvertently given exhibits by court staff regarding the scheduling of potential key witness Bryce Eggleston.
Abbott vacated the previous day’s verdict against Ellsworth from the bench Wednesday afternoon.
“It’s possible there were exhibits that were sent to the jury room that weren’t supposed to be there,” Abbott said. “As the parties recall, [the exhibits] were essentially put into the record for appellate purposes under seal on the first day of trial during jury selection, were included with the exhibits, but legally were not admitted as evidence and would not normally be relevant.”
The mistaken provision of the material to jurors at the start of deliberations became known to Ellsworth’s legal team as they visited with a juror after the verdict was announced shortly after 8 p.m. Tuesday. The juror mentioned details considered by jurors that weren’t part of the trial.
RELATED
Jury finds Ellsworth guilty of official misconduct
A Helena jury found former state Senate President Jason Ellsworth guilty of misdemeanor criminal official misconduct for awarding $170,000 in no-bid contracts to a company represented by a long-time business associate. Jury deliberations took nearly four hours and left Ellsworth, a Hamilton Republican, potentially facing a six-month jail sentence. Ellsworth exited the courthouse shortly after…
“The state does believe that there should be a new trial,” said Dan Guzynski, an assistant Montana attorney general, speaking at a mistrial hearing Wednesday. “I also want to make a brief comment that everybody makes mistakes, and this whole process, and what we’re all involved in, is subject to the human condition.”
Eggleston is Ellsworth’s longtime friend and former employee, who in 2024 pitched the senator on tracking the state’s progress implementing 27 legislative bills created by lawmakers with the purpose of curtailing the powers of Montana courts. Ellsworth signed two contracts totaling $170,000 for the proposed services on Dec. 26, 2024.
The work was to be performed by Agile Analytics, a then newly formed company for which Eggleston was the registered agent. Prosecutors allege that Ellsworth circumvented competitive bidding requirements and signed the contracts without a required review by state procurement agents.
Eggleston informed the Legislature in early 2025 that Agile was no longer interested in the work after Ellsworth’s handling of the agreements drew public attention.
Eggleston told Montana Free Press he didn’t want to discuss Wednesday’s hearing, which he wasn’t part of, but agreed to share his email communications with Guszynski about scheduling in the weeks leading up to Ellsworth’s trial. Those communications were inadvertently provided to the jurors prior to deliberations Tuesday night.
In the communications, Eggleston explains that he cannot attend the trial in person on the day requested by the Department of Justice due to parental obligations. He offers to testify remotely on the day requested, or in person on a different day of the trial, which was scheduled to last two weeks.
Guszynski informed Eggleston that Ellsworth objected to Eggleston testifying remotely. Guszynski then suggested that the senator’s objection “seems strategic and smacks of gamesmanship all around” — an accusation that was never raised at trial, since the state chose not to call Eggleston as a witness.
Jury deliberations following the six-day trial took four hours on Tuesday and left Ellsworth, a Hamilton Republican, potentially facing a six-month jail sentence for mishandling the two contracts awarded to Agile Analytics.
Should the Department of Justice choose to retry the case, the retrial would begin Dec. 14, Abbott said.
Ellsworth’s Senate term expires at the end of the year.
LATEST STORIES
Where air conditioning is most — and least — common in Montana
About 73% of occupied Montana homes had air conditioning in 2023, according to a new Census Bureau data series. But rates varied widely across the state, from nearly 96% in Custer County to less than 45% in Deer Lodge County. Montana’s overall rate is the fifth-lowest in the nation, and trails all of the states…
A history runs through it: Zinke public lands bill follows long trail
Two decades of Wilderness debate took an unexpected turn on Sept. 9 when Montana Republican Rep. Ryan Zinke announced a bill creating 132,000 acres of new wilderness alongside 181,000 acres of forest restoration areas and 60,000 acres where motorized and bike recreation activity would be permanently authorized. Can Zinke get the bill through Congress before…
After weeks of public outcry, Yellowstone County asks state to clarify 2025 data center law
In a letter signed this week, Yellowstone County commissioners asked local legislators to review a new law they said is stopping them from regulating the 5,000-acre project near Broadview by developer Quantica Infrastructure. The letter, approved Tuesday, is addressed to the “Members of the Yellowstone County Legislative Delegation” and asks them to “refine” a 2025…
