Teachers and staff attend to protest and comment at the November Board of Trustees meeting of Billings Public Schools Nov. 16, 2026, in Billings. Credit: Phoebe Tollefson, MTFP

A proposed 24% salary increase for the Billings Public Schools superintendent continued to draw criticism this week, even as many voiced support for Erwin Garcia’s leadership. 

The Board of Trustees didn’t take an up-or-down vote on the raise itself at its meeting Monday night, but instead referred the question of whether to amend Garcia’s current contract to the Board Operations Committee, which Chair Janna Hafer said would likely meet Thursday. 

Board Operations is where negotiations for the superintendent’s contract are supposed to take place, under district policy. But in this case, those talks began at a special board meeting, called in response to information that Garcia was interviewing for another superintendent job elsewhere. Garcia declined to confirm any details about that interview in a Tuesday text message with Montana Free Press.

Hafer told MTFP Monday night that she called the special meeting to ensure all board members could weigh in, and that she alone wouldn’t decide whether to open the door to mid-year contract talks aimed at keeping Garcia on board. 

Garcia’s current salary is $217,095. The proposal was to increase that to $270,000. 

His current salary tops the superintendent salaries in Bozeman, Missoula, Helena and Great Falls, district data show. The proposed raise would have made him better paid than his counterparts in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, and Boise, Idaho, both of which have more students. 

In response to community backlash about his potential raise, Garcia told MTFP he has helped usher in pay raises for teachers during his first few years in Billings. Average teacher pay has increased by 16% since 2023, when Garcia took the job, according to a district spreadsheet. Garcia’s base salary increased by $12,095 in his first contract renewal, but in the two subsequent years he declined a salary increase. 

“Superintendents often forgo salary increases as a gesture of goodwill,” Garcia wrote via text to MTFP. “In discussions about extending my contract for three years my goal was to bring it in line with national and regional averages for districts of similar enrollment and at-risk population.” 

In the special meeting where the proposed raise was first discussed, the board voted 4-4 against the increase. The Budget Committee, separate from the full board, then reviewed a wealth of data on compensation for other superintendents in the region, the costs of retaining Garcia versus hiring a new superintendent and other topics before recommending that Garcia’s requested raise be denied. Hafer said the next step was for the operations committee to consider contract talks with Garcia. His current one-year contract began in July. 

At their regular monthly meeting Monday night, trustees listened as support staff and teachers expressed frustration with the proposed raise, often comparing it to the 1.5% raise teachers received this past year. Commenters said many were struggling to make ends meet. 

Tessa Olson, a technology employee for the district whose kids attend Billings Public Schools, said she works a second job and has been dismayed to see student programs cut, funding for curriculum suffer and open support staff positions closed. She said the district has given “massive raises” to administrators while hollowing out support at the school level. 

“Every dollar sent upward is a dollar taken away from the classroom where our children actually learn,” Olson said. 

The boardroom at the Lincoln Center was full, with many in the audience wearing red T-shirts in support of educators, a nod to the Red for Ed grassroots campaign nationwide. 

Many who criticized the proposed raise commended Garcia’s work but noted a simultaneous multimillion-dollar deficit in the district’s high school budget. everal commenters tried to pivot the conversation toward what they saw as a more important concern than superintendent pay: the school funding formula. The state’s funding formula is hundreds of millions of dollars short of adequately funding Montana school districts, according to the School Funding Interim Commission. 

Several board members expressed support for Garcia’s leadership. Trustee Brooke Wagner said being fiscally conservative didn’t mean simply “not spending money,” but rather making “smart” investments. 

“Under Dr. Garcia’s leadership, I’ve seen our district grow in ways that, frankly, I never thought were possible while my kids were still in school,” Wagner said. “I recognize that these achievements have not been the result of one person’s work, but the work of a district as a whole. But retaining excellent leadership has a cost. And it’s not who is worth more — teachers or superintendent. That’s not the question we’re asking. I’m not sure there’s enough money in the world that would reflect the true value of our teachers and staff. Our district needs stability and accountability and continued growth in a positive direction. There is value in recognizing this and retaining quality leadership.”

Speaking to MTFP on the Friday before the meeting, Garcia said he and his family would “love” to stay in Billings, calling it “an amazing community.” But, he said, his salary has to be competitive. 

“And without a doubt right now it is not,” he said.

LATEST STORIES

Phoebe Tollefson joined the MTFP Local team to cover Billings in 2026. She has worked at The Sheridan Press and The Billings Gazette, where she spent years reporting on criminal justice, courts and other local policy issues. Her work has appeared in McClatchy Newspapers and the Chicago Sun-Times. Phoebe is a graduate of the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University. She lives in her hometown of Billings. Contact Phoebe at [email protected].