A federal judge on Tuesday ordered the United States to pay the Fort Belknap Indian Community $151,199 for an accounting error, but rejected the tribes’ primary claim that it had been unfairly denied funding for law enforcement services on the reservation. The ruling brings to a close a years-long dispute regarding public safety in the tribal community.
The Fort Belknap Indian Community in north-central Montana filed the lawsuit in 20222 against the United States, the Department of the Interior and several Bureau of Indian Affairs officials, alleging that federal funding for law enforcement services on the reservation was “insufficient to provide the most basic law enforcement services” and that the lack of funding violated the tribes’ contract with the government.
The lawsuit underscores a longstanding frustration of tribes and political leaders with law enforcement funding in Indian Country. In 2022, the Northern Cheyenne Tribe in southeast Montana sued the Bureau of Indian Affairs and Department of the Interior, alleging the federal government failed to provide adequate public safety services on the reservation. State lawmakers have passed several resolutions urging Congress to fully fund law enforcement in tribal communities, and Republican and Democratic members of Montana’s congressional delegation have routinely criticized the Bureau of Indian Affairs for public safety deficiencies in Indian Country. State and tribal leaders say the lack of investment perpetuates violence and contributes to high rates of missing and murdered Indigenous people nationwide.
In 1997, the Fort Belknap Aaniiih and Nakoda Tribes entered a contractual agreement with the federal government that the tribes would assume authority over law enforcement services on their tribal land. Law enforcement on the Fort Belknap Reservation had previously been operated by the federal government. Under the agreement, the tribes oversee day-to-day law enforcement operations, and the Bureau of Indian Affairs provides technical support, occasional reviews and funding for the program.
In their 2022 complaint, the Fort Belknap Indian Community alleged that the tribes received $1.2 million in funding for law enforcement in 1997, the year the agreement was signed, and that the allocation had remained “very near” that level in the almost 30 intervening years.
In 2022, the tribes said, the funding supported 16 law enforcement employees, including seven officers responsible for patrolling the nearly 700,000-acre reservation.
The tribes’ complaint alleged that insufficient funding resulted in “a chronic shortage of patrol officers and dispatch personnel” and contributed to “high levels of violent crimes, property crimes and substance abuse.”
The plaintiffs also alleged that lack of funding prevented them from being able to hire specialists, including drug investigators, missing and murdered Indigenous people special agents, school resource officers and victims specialists, among other personnel.
In 2022, when the tribes requested more than $5 million in funding for law enforcement, the Bureau of Indian Affairs granted $1.35 million.
In court documents, the tribes claimed the federal government provided better funding to other, similar tribes and that the government’s refusal to grant the increase violated their contract.
The federal agency wrote in a letter to tribal leaders that the tribes were “not entitled” to the requested funding increase. Allotted funds are limited by congressional appropriations, the government claimed in court documents.
“In a perfect world, all tribes would receive funding to fully meet their law enforcement need,” according to the defendants. “In practice, very few do.”
Federal District Court Judge John Johnson found insufficient evidence to support the tribes’ claim that the government had unfairly rejected its funding request. He also noted an accounting error that resulted in reduced funding for the tribes.
When Congress approves an increase in appropriations for law enforcement in Indian Country, the Bureau of Indian Affairs uses a formula to allocate the increase to individual tribes. The formula weighs violent crime rates, program needs and land size, among other factors, Johnson wrote in his order.
Johnson found that in 2022 and 2023, the Bureau of Indian Affairs used inaccurate acreage data for the Fort Belknap Indian Community when calculating the disbursement of congressional funds. The error, which carried over to 2024, 2025 and 2026, “reduced the funding Fort Belknap Indian Community was entitled to receive” in violation of the tribes’ contract with the federal government, Johnson found.
He ordered the federal government to pay the tribes $151,199 to account for the error plus interest.
LATEST STORIES
Federal judge denies tribal claim for increased law enforcement funding
A federal judge has ordered the United States to pay the Fort Belknap Indian Community $151,199 for an accounting error, but rejected the tribes’ primary claim that it had been unfairly denied funding for law enforcement services in the tribal community.
Senate leaders announce plan to investigate sexual misconduct allegations against longtime legislator Jonathan Windy Boy
Republican and Democratic leaders in the state Senate have announced a plan to address allegations of sexual misconduct against Sen. Jonathan Windy Boy, D-Box Elder. The Senate president and minority leader said they plan to refer the issue to the Senate Ethics Committee for investigation when the Legislature convenes in January.
As federal employees disappear, Red Rock Lakes is struggling
Sources are saying the wildlife refuge system has lost as much as 36 percent of its workforce since January 2025. This GYE refuge is feeling the pinch.


