This story is excerpted from the MT Lowdown, a weekly newsletter digest containing original reporting and analysis published every Friday.
Back in 2021, Republican-led changes to Montana election laws produced a pitched legal battle, with critics arguing that new voter ID requirements and a ban on same-day registration made it harder to exercise one of Americansโ most fundamental rights. Now a similar challenge has emerged against an election administration measure passed by this yearโs Legislature that puts stricter requirements on voter registration.
On Oct. 3, the Montana Federation of Public Employees and the Montana Public Interest Research Group (MontPIRG) filed a lawsuit in federal court in Helena alleging that this yearโs House Bill 892 violates the U.S. Constitution. The law was framed by proponents as an effort to prevent individuals from voting in two separate locations during a single election โ what it refers to as โdouble votingโ โ by requiring that they provide previous registration information when registering to vote in a new location in Montana. Failure to comply with HB 892 could result in a $5,000 fine, 18 months in jail or both.
Rep. Lyn Hellegaard, R-Missoula, argued while carrying the bill that double voting is a โmanipulation of the electoral franchiseโ that should not be tolerated in Montana. The measure picked up a smattering of Democratic votes in the House.
In their court challenge, MFPE and MontPIRG counter that the new law goes much further than Montanaโs previous ban on such activity, which simply stated that โno person may vote more than once at an election.โ They also say they believe the new law isnโt clear enough about what information it requires would-be voters to provide and that the criminal penalties for failing to comply will โchill political expression in Montana by making it riskier for individuals to register to vote.โ Taken together, the plaintiffs contend, that stacks up to a violation of the right to vote and the right to due process. Theyโve asked the U.S. District Court in Helena to declare the law unconstitutional and to bar its enforcement.
Two of the three defendants โ Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen and Commissioner of Political Practices Chris Gallus โ declined to comment on the litigation last week. A spokesperson for Attorney General Austin Knudsen, the third defendant, said Knudsen will โdefend the law.โ Knudsenโs office is expected to file a response to the complaint within the next month.
LATEST STORIES
Judge sends Great Falls man back to prison for sexually assaulting two girls
In an evidentiary hearing, Cascade County District Court Judge David Grubich found that Reese Riggin, 60, violated the conditions of his probation and will return to prison to serve the remaining 10 years on his sentence from 2016 for his conviction of sexual intercourse without consent.
Montanaโs midterm election turnout rate held steady, while county results varied widely
Montana voter turnout was nearly unchanged from the last midterm election, but a county-by-county look reveals substantial differences in where voters showed up at the polls. Turnout declined in most Montana counties, with Golden Valley County, in central Montana, recording the largest drop at 14 percentage points. Substantial increases in Glacier and Blaine, two of Montanaโs four majority-Native counties, stand out against the statewide trend.
Federal judge denies tribal claim for increased law enforcement fundingย
A federal judge has ordered the United States to pay the Fort Belknap Indian Community $151,199 for an accounting error, but rejected the tribesโ primary claim that it had been unfairly denied funding for law enforcement services in the tribal community.


