Two Montana lawmakers were given taxpayer funds last fall to reimburse their attendance at a three-day “cyber symposium” in South Dakota where the host, MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell, perpetuated debunked allegations of widespread election fraud in the 2020 presidential election.
According to records obtained by Montana Free Press from the Legislative Services Division, Rep. Bob Phalen, R-Lindsay, was reimbursed $979.37 for lodging and mileage expenses incurred during his trip to the symposium. Rep. Paul Fielder, R-Thompson Falls, was likewise reimbursed $528.04 for mileage. The reimbursements were drawn from constituent services funds allocated to help Montana lawmakers communicate with and represent their constituents and attend events in service of constituent interests.
Phalen and Fielder were among six Republican legislators identified by the website Missoula County Tyranny as having attended the symposium in August. Records show that the other attending lawmakers — Rep. Steve Galloway, R-Great Falls; Rep. Jerry Schillinger, R-Circle; Rep. Brad Tschida, R-Missoula; and Sen. Theresa Manzella, R-Stevensville — did not file requests for constituent services reimbursements related to the event.
In an email to MTFP Monday, Fielder responded to questions about the constituent benefit of attending Lindell’s symposium by citing a section of the Montana Constitution directing legislators to “insure the purity of elections and guard against abuses of the electoral process.” Fielder wrote that if a single voter in his district had their vote “canceled out by an illegal vote” cast elsewhere in the district, state or nation, “that is a concern to me.”
Election fraud argument gets an audience with Montana’s Department of Justice
Attorney General Austin Knudsen’s office has confirmed a previously unreported meeting with MyPillow founder Mike Lindell and election skeptic state Sen. Theresa Manzella, R-Stevensville, on Nov. 10. At the time, Lindell was attempting to gain the support of state attorneys general in a lawsuit challenging the 2020 presidential election.
“The Cyber Symposium gave me a lot of information about irregularities in the 2020 election,” Fielder continued, “and put me in touch with a lot of election experts and other legislators in other states that are working on election integrity issues so that I can better fulfill my oath to defend and protect the constitution of the U.S.A. and Montana.”
Phalen did not respond to an email posing the same questions. Phalen did provide comment to the Glendive Ranger-Review, quoting the same section of the Montana Constitution as Fielder and saying he attended the symposium “to learn more on what had taken place in the Nov. 2020 election, and that is what I brought back home.” Phalen also confirmed he had received a constituent services reimbursement.
“Another Representative, Jerry Schillinger [R-Circle] and I, have held seven election informational meetings since going to the symposium, and on February 4th we are holding another one in Wolf Point,” Phalen told the Ranger-Review. “So this is how it has helped my constituents.”
MTFP also reached out to Galloway, Schillinger, Manzella and Tschida to ask why they did not request reimbursements. Tschida did not respond to several requests. Manzella told MTFP she paid for the trip herself and noted she could still file for a reimbursement, adding that she’s unsure if she will. Schillinger recently informed MTFP that he traveled to the symposium with Phalen, who covered the mileage and lodging costs and obtained a reimbursement. Galloway explained via email that he has traveled to conventions and trainings in Florida, Texas, Utah and Washington, D.C., during his tenure in the Legislature. Most of those trips, he continued, were self-funded, including his attendance at the Lindell symposium.
“I just believe that being blessed to be successful in business for over 45 years, we can afford to give back in serving,” Galloway wrote. “I feel it’s very important to our constituents that we are as knowledgeable as possible.”
In the months after the August symposium, several of the attending lawmakers including Tschida and Manzella helped to organize similar symposiums around Montana. Those events featured presentations from a pair of national election skeptics alleging that voter fraud in Montana and nationwide resulted in President Donald Trump’s electoral defeat. Manzella previously informed MTFP that she also facilitated a Nov. 10 meeting between Lindell and Attorney General Austin Knudsen in an attempt to gain the latter’s support for a U.S. Supreme Court lawsuit challenging the 2020 election results. Knudsen did not join the effort, and Lindell’s lawsuit was never filed.
Election officials and political scientists have rejected the claims and information presented by Lindell and others at the South Dakota symposium and events in Montana as meritless, stating repeatedly that there is no evidence of voter fraud on the scale or with the intent alleged by Trump’s supporters.
Last week, Seattle Times political reporter Jim Brunner reported that three Washington lawmakers were similarly reimbursed with taxpayer funds for their trips to Lindell’s symposium. Those lawmakers — Republican Reps. Vicki Kraft, Robert Sutherland and Brad Klippert — claimed a total of $4,361 for lodging and airfare. The reimbursements prompted the editorial board of the Tri-City Herald to request that Klippert apologize to taxpayers and that he and the others pay the money back to the state.
“While it isn’t an exorbitant amount,” the board wrote on Jan. 7, “public money should not be spent perpetuating a false narrative — especially one that sabotages our democratic system.”
According to reporting by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel last fall, former Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Michael Gableman also utilized taxpayer funds to travel to the South Dakota symposium. In that case, the money came from funding for an investigation into the state’s 2020 presidential election results ordered by the Wisconsin Assembly and headed by Gableman.
Tschida and Manzella have repeatedly pressed fellow lawmakers to pursue their own investigation of election security in Montana, and were among 86 Republican legislators who signed a letter last fall formally requesting the formation of a special legislative committee for that purpose. Tschida urged the state’s Legislative Council last month to consider using federal relief funds for the effort and estimated the cost at roughly $50,000. To date, legislative leadership has taken no action on the request.
This story was updated Jan. 31, 2022, to include additional information about symposium expenses incurred by Rep. Bob Phalen, Rep. Steve Galloway, Rep. Jerry Schillinger, Rep. Brad Tschida, and Sen. Theresa Manzella.
House Bill committee tables exempt-well bill
With little in the way of discussion, the House Natural Resources Committee amended and then tabled HB 642. As originally proposed, HB 642 would have granted some existing well owners access to additional groundwater and expanded the permitting loophole to allow larger subdivisions additional groundwater without going through a permitting process.
Proposed constitutional amendment would end Montana Supreme Court elections
A proposed constitutional amendment to allow for gubernatorial appointment of Montana Supreme justices is making its way through the Legislature.
Senate committee tables bill to dismantle adult-use cannabis industry
The Senate Business, Labor and Economic Affairs Committee unanimously tabled Sen. Keith Regier’s Senate Bill 546, which would have dismantled Montana’s adult-use cannabis program and put significant restrictions on the state’s medical marijuana program.