This story is adapted from the MT Lowdown, a weekly newsletter digest containing original reporting and analysis published every Friday.
A federal agency that oversees hydroelectric dams has been roped, again, into an ongoing dispute about water levels in Flathead Lake. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission received a pair of letters this month related to its ability to referee dam management to sustain water levels in the largest natural freshwater lake west of the Mississippi.
The dispute stems from last summer’s uncharacteristically low lake levels, which frustrated lakefront property owners accustomed to using their docks through the summer and squeezed businesses reliant on lake-supported recreation.
In January, the National Organization to Save Flathead Lake petitioned FERC to intervene in the management of the Séliš Ksanka QÍispé Dam (formerly Kerr Dam), which is owned by the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes. The 39-year-old 501(c)(4) argued that previous dam operators managed to navigate drought without such sharp drops during the summer boating season. Energy Keepers, Inc., a CSKT-owned company that assumed management of the dam in 2015, countered that a modest snowpack, record-breaking springtime temperatures and stipulations of its license related to fisheries and dam discharge rates all played a role in the diminished lake.
RELATED
What’s to blame for too little water in Flathead Lake: climate or mismanagement?
The dam-managed lake at the headwaters of the Columbia River system was on Aug. 10 more than 2 feet below “full pool,” or the ideal level for using the lake’s numerous docks and ramps. Accusations of mismanagement have been flying while the dam operators point to the role of a rapid runoff of a modest snowpack.
Zinke introduces bill to ‘fill’ Flathead Lake after summer of low water
The “Fill the Lake Act” is meant to address problems that Zinke says were “exacerbated by the slow-working bureaucracy” this past summer. Others blamed the low water levels on something much bigger: drought and climate change.
FERC examined the petition the National Organization to Save Flathead Lake submitted and in February issued a letter to EKI finding that the company “fully operated” the dam “in compliance with [its] license.”
The saga continues, though: On March 1, the Lake County Commission submitted a letter to FERC requesting its intervention to prevent what it called the “real and dangerous public safety threat” posed by EKI’s management of the SKQ Dam. The letter argues that a low lake level could result in a loss of human life because it “negates any use of a secondary escape route for residents due to wildfire.”
“The numerous excuses previously used such as climate change, contractual obligations, lower than average snowpacks, water for downstream fisheries, etc. will be of little use following a devastating wildfire that may result in the loss of human life,” the letter reads.
The letter also outlines proposed dam management changes that could preserve such secondary escape routes. They include amending components of EKI’s license geared toward supporting fisheries and endangered species, directing EKI to curtail its springtime lake drawdown in drought years, and requiring the federal agency that operates the Hungry Horse Reservoir, which feeds into Flathead Lake, to “become more oriented towards helping relieve the impacts of drought” than toward flood control.
The county commissioners also suggested the tribes “consider leasing SKQ Dam to a corporation that has more experience and expertise in managing a hydroelectric facility.”
On March 20, attorneys for EKI and the CSKT, which uses dam-related revenue to support tribal operations, fired back a sharply worded response accusing the commission of creating “manufactured public safety concerns” that are “disingenuous at best.”
“Quite simply, the County’s Petition is nothing more than an effort to ensure a constant summer lake level to benefit a small group of lakefront dock owners — forcing the Licensees to curtail revenue from, and stream flows benefitting Tribal fisheries and other natural resources below, the project,” the response reads.
The attorneys write that the county seeks to “improperly shirk its own responsibilities to address wildfire safety and evacuation routes through its planning and zoning” and argue that the remedies commissioners seek — including forcing EKI to lease the dam to another operator — are outside FERC’s regulatory authority.
As of March 21, the Flathead basin had 75% of its typical snowpack.
This story was updated March 27, 2024, to corrrect when the National Organization to Save Flathead Lake was founded.
LATEST STORIES
Biden taps CSKT attorney Danna Jackson for U.S. District Court judgeship
President Joe Biden has tapped Danna Jackson, an attorney for the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, to replace Judge Dana Christensen in the U.S. District Court of Montana. Jackson, a former U.S. attorney who served as chief legal counsel to the Montana Department of Natural Resources from 2016 to 2021, would be the first Native American federal judge in Montana if her nomination is confirmed.
Republican candidates told not to attend Trump Jr. event in Missoula
At least two Republican candidates for state and federal offices have had their ticket purchases refunded and been told they cannot attend a high-profile GOP campaign event in Missoula.
Tim Sheehy, in his own words
Tim Sheehy sat down for a “fireside chat” with a fellow party member, providing a glimpse into how the candidate, who is hoping to defeat longtime Democratic incumbent Sen. Jon Tester this year, views his campaign and some of the controversies Democrats have hoped would dog him on the campaign trail.