A proposed property tax cap and three other ballot initiatives supporters had hoped to put before Montana voters in Novemberโs general election are dead in the water after failing to meet signature-gathering thresholds, their respective backers have said.
The failed proposals included CI-121, which would have amended the state Constitution to dramatically reconfigure Montanaโs tax system by capping residential property taxes. That initiative, sponsored by Bozeman attorney Matt Monforton and State Auditor Troy Downing, had drawn opposition from organizations across Montanaโs political spectrum, including the Montana Federation of Public Employees and the Montana Association of Realtors.
The tax cap measureโs opponents spent about $300,000 lobbying against it, said Montana Association of Realtors Government Affairs Director Sam Sill.
โA broad swath of Montanans recognized that this was going to be a disaster for the state,โ Sill said. โIt wasnโt going to be tax relief. It was going to be a tax shift, and the unintended consequences of it were going to be really terrifying.โ
related
The initiative that could upend Montanaโs tax system
CI-121, inspired by Californiaโs Prop 13 tax revolt, would cap residential property tax growth in the name of keeping Montanans from being priced out of their homes. The fiscal consequences could ripple across the state for generations.
In an emailed statement Thursday, Monforton blamed the measureโs defeat on litigation that temporarily enjoined supporters from gathering signatures and opposition spending by โa conglomerate of liberal special interests and tax-and-spend Republicans.โ
โThe Legislature is addicted to overtaxing homeowners,โ Monforton added. โThis is a problem that is not going away. We will circulate a new initiative beginning in June 2023, which will give us plenty of time to qualify for the November 2024 ballot.โ
Also failing to clear the signature-gathering threshold were CI-122, an election-reform measure, public preschool measure CI-123, and river protection measure I-191.
Montanans will, however, have the chance to vote on two measures referred to the ballot by the 2021 Montana Legislature. The first, C-48, would amend the Montana Constitution to explicitly specify that โelectronic data and communicationsโ are included in the clause that protects Montanans from โunreasonable searches and seizures.โ Sponsored by Sen. Kenneth Bognar, R-Miles City, the measure passed the Legislature last year with bipartisan support.
The second proposal that will go before voters, LR-131, the Montana Born-Alive Infant Protection Act, is an anti-abortion measure that specifies that any infant born alive โmust be treated as a legal person.โ It passed the Legislature with GOP support on near party line votes.
The Montana Constitution provides a pathway for enacting law by voter initiative as a way for Montana citizens to craft policy in the face of inaction by the state Legislature. In order to qualify for the ballot, initiative backers must gather signatures from 5% of the stateโs qualified voters, a 30,180-signature threshold this year. Initiatives that seek to modify the text of the state Constitution, rather than simply state law, face a higher 10% threshold: 60,359 signatures this year.
Before being submitted to voters, both types of initiatives must also meet requirements for gathering signatures from a certain number of legislative districts across the state. Initiatives and constitutional amendments that qualify for the ballot take effect if a majority of voters endorse them.
The signature-gathering bar proved too high a hurdle for this yearโs crop of initiatives, however, particularly given that some spent time tied up in litigation.
Some of the tax cap measureโs opponents, for example, filed suit in January arguing that Attorney General Austin Knudsen hadnโt fully complied with a new law governing how initiatives with potential impact on Montana businesses are reviewed before backers are allowed to gather signatures. Signature gathering was temporarily blocked by a district court judge in Helena, but a Bozeman judge dismissed the case in April.
Two other measures advanced by John Meyer, executive director of Bozeman-based Cottonwood Environmental Law Center, also wonโt make this yearโs ballot, Meyer said earlier this month.
The first, CI-123, would have amended the state Constitution to include โprekindergartenโ as part of the public education system guaranteed to Montanans. The second, I-191, would have designated portions of the Gallatin and Madison rivers as โOutstanding Resource Waters,โ bypassing the stateโs existing review process for that designation, which provides waterways with enhanced environmental protections.
In an email, Meyer blamed the failure of both measures on having his attention consumed by litigation against Montana Attorney General Austin Knuden, who had ruled CI-123 legally insufficient. That ruling prevented signature gathering on the measure until the insufficiency ruling was overturned by the Montana Supreme Court June 2.
I-191 was approved for signature gathering as of April 5 and CI-123 was approved for signature gathering on June 3. Both measures faced a June 17 deadline for submitting the required signatures to county election offices.
CI-122, this electionโs fourth proposed initiative, would have amended the state Constitution so candidates would need to win elections with at least 50% of the vote, instead of simply winning the most votes of any candidate in their race, as is currently the case. The amendment would have directed the Montana Legislature to write laws to determine how to deal with elections in which no candidates win majorities, as when candidates in a three-way race each receive less than 50% of the vote.
Sponsor Chris Shipp, a Republican political consultant, said Thursday that CI-122 wouldnโt qualify for the ballot this year.
Disclosure: Montana Free Press reporter Amanda Eggert is married to Meyer. She was not involved in the production of this story.
latest stories
PSC approves NorthWestern merger
State regulators this week approved of Montanaโs largest utility merging with South Dakota company Black Hills Corporation. Montana is the last state to grant regulatory approval of the merger. The vote passed on narrow margins 3 to 2, and saw mostly negative feedback from the public concerning increasing power bills and agreements to power dataโฆ
Air Force eyes reactivation of dormant Montana missile field as Sentinel project grows in scope
The Air Force is exploring the reactivation of a north-central Montana nuclear missile field, roughly the size of Rhode Island, as part of the Department of Defense’s Sentinel project to replace the land-based arsenal of intercontinental ballistic missiles, or ICBMs.
What happens to the cash when the campaigning ends?ย
Federal candidates and incumbents often leave political life with sizable balances in their campaign committee coffers. And constituents frequently ask journalists what happens to the money politicians leave on the table.


