This story is excerpted from Capitolized, a weekly newsletter with expert reporting, analysis and insight from the editors and reporters of Montana Free Press. Want to see Capitolized in your inbox every Thursday? Sign up here.
Broadwater County Attorney Cory Swanson announced his candidacy for Montana Supreme Court this week, setting up a contest between Swanson and former federal magistrate court judge Jerry Lynch for the court’s chief justiceship.
“When Montanans go to court, they expect a fair judge who will issue rulings based on the facts and the law, not on ideology,” he said Wednesday in a campaign announcement on the conservative radio show Montana Talks. “I’m committed to being a fair and impartial chief justice, who will interpret the law and not legislate from the bench. Montana voters should demand that of every judge and judicial candidate.”
Swanson, a 2004 graduate of the University of Montana law school, served as a deputy attorney general under Republican Tim Fox in 2013 and 2014, and began his tenure as Broadwater County Attorney the next year.
Reached by phone Thursday, he said he wants to provide voters with a choice for the open chief justice spot. Previously, only Lynch was in the race, following the bow-out of former state auditor John Morrison.
RELATED
Who’s running for office in Montana in 2024? Here’s a running list.
Montana’s 2024 ballot will host a suite of consequential elections — among them a race that could decide the balance of the U.S. Senate, two open seats on the Montana Supreme Court, two U.S. House races, Montana’s governorship and a bevy of statewide offices. Here’s who’s queuing up to run.
“Lynch has had a distinguished career,” Swanson said, “but I come from a different background, I present a good contrast.”
He noted that most of Lynch’s career on the bench has been spent as a member of the federal court system, and that Swanson’s recent experience as a local prosecutor gives him a fresh perspective.
There are two open seats on the Montana Supreme Court this election cycle, owing to the successive announcements by incumbent Chief Justice Mike McGrath and Associate Justice Dirk Sandefur that they are not seeking re-election.
Judicial politics have reached a fever pitch in recent years, with a protracted separation-of-powers conflict over legislative subpoena power, a spate of constitutional challenges to laws passed by the newly empowered GOP legislative majority, and attacks by members of that party — prominently including Attorney General Austin Knudsen — on the judiciary’s integrity and independence. Those critics often accuse the justices of “legislating from the bench” — in other words, handing down rulings that expand the meaning of the law rather than ruling based strictly on its text.
Swanson was unwilling to accuse the high court of any specific bias, but said voters want a jurist who’s willing to clearly state that a judge must be willing “to set aside their own preferences and decide a case” on the merits.
He also said he feels that some contemporary criticism of the judiciary is unfounded, and that judges inevitably have occasion to interpret the law beyond what’s strictly written.
“The court should do its very best to leave the policy advocacy issues to the political branches, it should do its very best to interpret the statutes and evaluate them relative to constitutional claims,” he said.
As of Thursday, district court judges Katherine Bidegaray and Dan Wilson have declared their candidacies for Sandefur’s seat on the high court.
LATEST STORIES
Medicaid unwinding deals a blow to a tenuous system of care for Native Americans
About a year into the process of redetermining Medicaid eligibility after the COVID-19 public health emergency, more than 20 million people nationwide have been kicked off the joint federal-state program for low-income families. Native Americans are proving particularly vulnerable to losing coverage and face greater obstacles to re-enrolling in Medicaid or finding other coverage.
Gianforte pushes university regents to restrict transgender athletes
A May 14 letter from the governor to Montana’s higher education governing board follows a court ruling that a 2021 law restricting athletic participation by transgender women usurped the regents’ authority.
Introducing the Big Sky kebab burger
With its heavy Turkish influence, my reinvented kebab burger is like a flavorful skewered meatloaf in tube form. It’s almost like an uncased sausage. Give it a try and I’m willing to bet it finds its way into your summer grilling rotation.